OK, that little song Rockin' Robin by Bobby Day pops in my head when I think of our newest Superstar, Robin.
In honor of the extra "leap day" in February we are giving you a second posting this month. Woo Hoo! Robin's Band Theory blog can be found at: http://bandtheory.blogspot.com/
I first met Robin in Chicago as we have been roomies for the last two BOOBS. Although she "seems" to be a bit quiet at first, she is really a Rockin' Robin and one of the warmest people you could ever know. She had already lost a good amount of weight when she jumped into blogging but has been an inspiration to us all. Her first post told us a bit about herself. She's originally from Detroit!
But today she's out in Colorado, living the good life now that she's lost almost half her body weight. And she lives out in the country with her cats and dogs (and a hubby too!), raises chickens, tends her gardens, works as an EMT, square dances, loves cruises...
I get tired just thinking about all the stuff she can now do effortlessly because the band helped her lose weight for good. Without further ado, here's Robin!
1. All about You!
Please tell us a little bit about yourself (age, how long you have had the band, etc.). Also, please include information about your pre-op diet and whether you were self-pay or covered by insurance. Include details about your doctor if you like. Tell us why you decided to get the Lap-Band (as opposed to other weight loss surgery or weight loss methods).
As you got closer to your goal, was your weight loss slower?
Weight loss has definitely been slower since getting closer to goal. In the early days I could count on losing 10 pounds a month with no problems. Once I got down to approximately 170 pounds (Nov. 2010) I've lost 14 pounds... barely one pound a month.
Did you experience plateaus? What did you do to shake up weight loss stalls?
When I was in my active losing phase, I really didn't have any plateaus. I steadily lost weight.
How did you decide on a goal weight?
Which band rules do you think are most important?
For me, not drinking while eating is important and stopping eating when full.
Did you track calories or log your food while you were losing weight? Do you do this now?
Did you find the mental aspect of losing weight difficult? (Including, for example, no longer relying on food for stress relief, getting used to seeing yourself as a “thin” person, or anything else)? How did you deal with this?
No mental issues here. What??? Instead of eating, I try to keep busy. I bought my laying chickens post-surgery, have planted a large garden, and enjoy a generally more active lifestyle. On occasion I have found myself eating out of boredom (like the time I ate most of a half-gallon of ice cream in an evening) but for whatever reason I am able to dust myself off and get on the straight and narrow quickly. In the past, when I was in a funk (or bored or mad or sad or whatever) I used to cook up a pound of pasta and eat most of it in one sitting (with plenty of butter). Once, since being banded, I've cooked a package of pasta for my emotions. I portioned out what I knew I could eat (one cup), put on plenty of butter, and chowed down. I then refrigerated the rest and made a dinner casserole out of it the next day. Sure I cursed a bit because I couldn't indulge myself, but on most levels, I was glad I couldn't.
Please tell us a little bit about yourself (age, how long you have had the band, etc.). Also, please include information about your pre-op diet and whether you were self-pay or covered by insurance. Include details about your doctor if you like. Tell us why you decided to get the Lap-Band (as opposed to other weight loss surgery or weight loss methods).
I'm 55 years old and had the band put in on July 22, 2009 (so about 2.5 years). I had my band surgery in Denver and my surgeon was Dr. Gerald Kirshenbaum. Dr. K was a pioneer in laparoscopic surgery (he was the first doc west of the Mississippi to do a cholecystectomy laparoscopically). Denver is about 400 miles from my home and there are no closer surgeons and/or fill doctors. I chose Dr. K mostly because of his low costs. Since I am a self-pay patient, cost was a consideration. Dr. K charged just under $10K for the surgery and had low-cost fills ($25). When assessing the cost of the surgery, I assumed I'd add another $2K a year (maybe for the rest of my life) for travel to have adjustments. Now of course Dr. K has since retired, but he has turned his records over to Dr. John Weaver who is honoring Dr. K's rate for fills. I went for my first fill with Dr. Weaver in December and am satisfied with his care.
I chose the lapband because it seemed so much less invasive than RNY or other bypass surgeries. I liked the adjustable nature of the device and I also liked the idea that no parts of my body were destroyed or permanently altered. In hindsight, I might have considered the sleeve, but again cost was a big consideration and no US based surgeon seemed to be doing the sleeve for a reasonable cost three years ago.
When I decided to have the surgery done, we were in a very fortunate situation. My husband had come into some money from a family business and we were in the process of paying down and refinancing the mortgage. I had cooked up the scheme to have the surgery using some of the business windfall. I hadn't had a chance to really discuss it with him when he was called out of town on business. At the same time, our mortgage closing was pushed up to the day Will flew home from his trip. I still didn't have time to discuss the surgery with him. As we walked into the mortgage closing I told him that I changed the mortgage numbers (how much we were paying down) and to trust me. If he didn't "approve" of what I was going to do with the money, we could just apply it to the mortgage after the closing. Luckily he trusted me (so that we didn't have any awkward moments at the closing) and he went along with my surgery plans.
2. Your Weight Loss:
Please let us know your starting weight and/or size, and current weight and/or size.
My highest weight, ever, was 307 in September of 2006. I lost nearly 100 pounds then using the coaching services and products of HNT. Unfortunately I fell off the bandwagon big-time and by the spring of 2009, I was back up to 278 pounds. My size at the time was 22 (pushing 24) in pants and 2 or 3 XL in shirts.
How long did it take you to get to your goal weight (or first 100 lbs. lost)?
I was 278 pounds when I had my initial (telephone) consultation with Dr. K. I did his 2-week pre-op diet for three weeks and lost 8 pounds. I weighed 270 on surgery day. It took me 16 months to lose my first 100 pounds. I've lost 114 pounds since surgery and have 3.5 more to go. Today my weight fluctuates between 155 and 159 pounds.
As you got closer to your goal, was your weight loss slower?
Weight loss has definitely been slower since getting closer to goal. In the early days I could count on losing 10 pounds a month with no problems. Once I got down to approximately 170 pounds (Nov. 2010) I've lost 14 pounds... barely one pound a month.
Did you experience plateaus? What did you do to shake up weight loss stalls?
When I was in my active losing phase, I really didn't have any plateaus. I steadily lost weight.
How did you decide on a goal weight?
My goal weight, 153.5 pounds is based on my all-time highest weight. Since my highest weight was 307, 50% of that seemed like a good goal.
Is your final goal weight considered “normal” on the BMI charts? At 5'6.5", 153.5 is a BMI of 24.4, just inside the normal weight range. My primary care physician is happy with my weight where it is (as am I for the most part) but she supports me losing the last couple of pounds for the psychological factor and the bragging rights.
Is your final goal weight considered “normal” on the BMI charts? At 5'6.5", 153.5 is a BMI of 24.4, just inside the normal weight range. My primary care physician is happy with my weight where it is (as am I for the most part) but she supports me losing the last couple of pounds for the psychological factor and the bragging rights.
3. All about Food!
Do you follow any of the band rules religiously? For someone who is generally a rule-follower, I really don't follow many of the rules very well. I'll list the rules as I found them on a website and comment afterwards.
1. Eat only three small meals a day (I'm a snacker. I eat three meals and generally three snacks.)
2. Eat slowly and chew thoroughly (15-20 times a bite) (I do eat slowly but I don't chew that thoroughly. I've had some dental issues so chewing isn't that fun for me.)
3. Stop eating as soon as you feel full (I try)
4. Do not drink while you are eating (This I adhere to religiously... well, except for wine with dinner. I cannot eat and drink without dire consequences.)
5. Do not eat between meals (I snack.)
6. Eat only good quality food (I mostly eat good quality food but do indulge in junk on occasion.)
7. Avoid fibrous food (I don't eat fibrous food.)
8. Drink enough fluids during the day (Usually)
9. Drink only low-calorie fluids (I do drink fancy coffee drinks and alcoholic beverages.)
10. Exercise at least 30 minutes a day (Embarrassingly, I've only started exercise in the past two months.)
1. Eat only three small meals a day (I'm a snacker. I eat three meals and generally three snacks.)
2. Eat slowly and chew thoroughly (15-20 times a bite) (I do eat slowly but I don't chew that thoroughly. I've had some dental issues so chewing isn't that fun for me.)
3. Stop eating as soon as you feel full (I try)
4. Do not drink while you are eating (This I adhere to religiously... well, except for wine with dinner. I cannot eat and drink without dire consequences.)
5. Do not eat between meals (I snack.)
6. Eat only good quality food (I mostly eat good quality food but do indulge in junk on occasion.)
7. Avoid fibrous food (I don't eat fibrous food.)
8. Drink enough fluids during the day (Usually)
9. Drink only low-calorie fluids (I do drink fancy coffee drinks and alcoholic beverages.)
10. Exercise at least 30 minutes a day (Embarrassingly, I've only started exercise in the past two months.)
Which band rules do you think are most important?
For me, not drinking while eating is important and stopping eating when full.
Did you track calories or log your food while you were losing weight? Do you do this now?
I have tracked my food every day since June of 2009. Granted, tracking may have gone by the wayside when I was on a cruise or other vacations, but I have consistently tracked my intake for the past 30 months.
Did you measure your portions? Do you do this now?
I really never measured my portions. Perhaps a few times I'd weigh or measure, but I generally just eyeball it or use pre-portioned food (yogurt cup, low-cal ice cream bar, a square of chocolate, etc.).
Describe a typical day of eating for you, both during your weight loss phase and now.
Food on a typical work day looks like this:
7:30 small cup of coffee with half and half
Did you measure your portions? Do you do this now?
I really never measured my portions. Perhaps a few times I'd weigh or measure, but I generally just eyeball it or use pre-portioned food (yogurt cup, low-cal ice cream bar, a square of chocolate, etc.).
Describe a typical day of eating for you, both during your weight loss phase and now.
Food on a typical work day looks like this:
7:30 small cup of coffee with half and half
9:00 Greek yogurt (should've bought stock in Fage three years ago) and a bit more coffee
12:00 either ¾ cup of some dinner leftovers, a Lean Cuisine type entree, or a can of soup
1:00 some sort of 100 calorie snack pack
3:00 snack (either protein shake made with leftover coffee, HNT protein, a bit of sugar-free/fat-free pudding mix, and coffee cubes or some cheese or leftover meat or gasp.... some chips)
7:00 dinner (same types of foods I've eaten my whole life... either meat & potatoes, casseroles, soups, etc. but in <1 cup portions) and a glass of wine
9:00 popcorn or a cookie or diet ice cream or real ice cream or whatever
Some lap band practices tell patients to eat only 3 small meals a day; some say 3 meals plus 1 or 2 snacks; some say 5 or 6 small meals. What did you do when you were losing weight, and what do you do now?
Both in the losing phase and now in the not-so-losing phase I would say I eat 5 to 6 small meals. I cannot eat a big meal and find that snacking (grazing) satisfies me. I keep it under control by tracking my food religiously.
Approximately how many calories per day did you eat during your weight loss, and how many now?
During my best weight loss phase, I averaged between 1200 and 1400 calories per day. And now, in what is basically an unintentional maintenance phase, I average about 1600 per day.
What are some of your favorite band-friendly foods?
Greek yogurt, cheese, protein shakes when I feel really snacky, pistachios (in the shell), egg salad, tuna salad, crab cakes.
Did you drink protein shakes during your weight loss phase? Do you now?
Some lap band practices tell patients to eat only 3 small meals a day; some say 3 meals plus 1 or 2 snacks; some say 5 or 6 small meals. What did you do when you were losing weight, and what do you do now?
Both in the losing phase and now in the not-so-losing phase I would say I eat 5 to 6 small meals. I cannot eat a big meal and find that snacking (grazing) satisfies me. I keep it under control by tracking my food religiously.
Approximately how many calories per day did you eat during your weight loss, and how many now?
During my best weight loss phase, I averaged between 1200 and 1400 calories per day. And now, in what is basically an unintentional maintenance phase, I average about 1600 per day.
What are some of your favorite band-friendly foods?
Greek yogurt, cheese, protein shakes when I feel really snacky, pistachios (in the shell), egg salad, tuna salad, crab cakes.
Did you drink protein shakes during your weight loss phase? Do you now?
Yes and yes. I love how mine fill me up and provide good quality protein.
Did you follow any special “diet” plan during your weight loss – for example, low carb, counting points on Weight Watchers, etc.?
Did you follow any special “diet” plan during your weight loss – for example, low carb, counting points on Weight Watchers, etc.?
No special diet.
Are there any foods you cannot eat with the band (like meat, bread, etc.)?
Are there any foods you cannot eat with the band (like meat, bread, etc.)?
I can pretty much eat anything as long as I'm careful. I do have some issues with grilled meat (steaks, chops, etc.) which kind of bums out my husband since he's the grillmaster in the family and does like to cook for me on the weekend. I don't do a lot of vegetables either. Some in soup or stews or casseroles and certain ones cooked plain, but in general, no salad. I find I can't chew it up finely enough to move through my band easily.
What would a “splurge” day be like for you? A splurge day?
What would a “splurge” day be like for you? A splurge day?
Hmmm. Maybe too much candy or chips or ice cream. Since I don't deny myself any of these things, I really don't have splurge days.
4. All About Fills!
What size band do you have, and what amount of fill do you have?
4. All About Fills!
What size band do you have, and what amount of fill do you have?
Wow, I know some folks know all their deets but I had to look this up. I have a 10cc LapBand. As for fill level, I have no clue. I did track the fills and unfills for a while, but lost track. My new surgeon thinks I have between 6.4 and 6.6 cc in my band.
How many fills did it take you to get to your “sweet spot”?
How many fills did it take you to get to your “sweet spot”?
I felt like I was at my sweet spot at my first fill, one month after surgery. During the initial quick weight loss phase, my sweet spot moved constantly. I had seven fill adjustments in the first year, including one partial de-fill.
Did you ever have to get a un-fill?
Did you ever have to get a un-fill?
I've had three partial de-fills. I was overly filled after my sixth fill. I could not eat nor drink anything. I had a slight de-fill and was in nirvana. That was in May 2010. I stayed at that fill level until April 2011. At that time I was again a bit overfilled but held out for a month until I had a scheduled trip to Denver. A slight unfill took care of the reflux that I was suffering from. I didn't have another fill until December 2011. That time I realized I had issues before I flew home and had the surgeon remove a bit of fluid before I left town. Right now I think I'm a bit too restricted but at this point, it's not worth over $500 to travel for an adjustment.
Can you drink water and other fluids easily at your fill level?
Can you drink water and other fluids easily at your fill level?
I can drink fluids pretty easily at my present fill level. Sometimes if I try to bolt down water it feels like a rock hitting my stoma, but normal, casual drinking is fine.
Do you get stuck and/or slime and/or PB very often?
Do you get stuck and/or slime and/or PB very often?
I don't get stuck too often. In terms of truly stuck or PB, at my worst, maybe once a week (and that was generally operator error). Normally, like now, I might get the wide-eyed, deer-in-the-headlights look once a week or so but that is more of a cautionary reaction telling me to slow down or stop. I do have some signals that tell me that I'm overdoing it. I either get hiccups or I sneeze when I've either eaten too much or too fast.
5. Share Your Secrets!
Tell us your best tips for losing weight with the band. What do you think contributed most to your success?
5. Share Your Secrets!
Tell us your best tips for losing weight with the band. What do you think contributed most to your success?
I really don't have any great tips for losing weight with the band or any secrets that contributed to my success. For me, I know I was ready to lose weight and keep it off. I spent a lot of money (hard earned by my husband's family) to have surgery and I feel a lot of pressure (commitment) to make it work. While I've felt jealousy of people who have the surgery paid for by insurance, I know that for me, having it come out of my bank account is extra incentive to make the tool work for me. For me, since I'm a snacker and always will be one, tracking my intake has been very important to losing my weight with the band. I could snack the whole day away but knowing that eating only xxxx calories will allow me to lose weight, tracking keeps me in the ballpark. (Of course now, nearly at goal, I don't quite have the incentive to keep at the lowest end of my calorie range.)
What advice do you have for Newbies? Is there anything you would have done differently if you could go back to the months right after your surgery?
What advice do you have for Newbies? Is there anything you would have done differently if you could go back to the months right after your surgery?
If I were to change one thing it would be to get serious about exercise from the start. I guess I had to be non-compliant on some level, and exercise was it. There, I admit it, I'm not an exerciser.
What is the best band-related advice you received?
What is the best band-related advice you received?
The band is only a tool. I had to do my part too.
How did you deal with “head hunger”?
How did you deal with “head hunger”?
I still have it. I tend to just push it away or enjoy small portions of a snack.
Did you find the mental aspect of losing weight difficult? (Including, for example, no longer relying on food for stress relief, getting used to seeing yourself as a “thin” person, or anything else)? How did you deal with this?
No mental issues here. What??? Instead of eating, I try to keep busy. I bought my laying chickens post-surgery, have planted a large garden, and enjoy a generally more active lifestyle. On occasion I have found myself eating out of boredom (like the time I ate most of a half-gallon of ice cream in an evening) but for whatever reason I am able to dust myself off and get on the straight and narrow quickly. In the past, when I was in a funk (or bored or mad or sad or whatever) I used to cook up a pound of pasta and eat most of it in one sitting (with plenty of butter). Once, since being banded, I've cooked a package of pasta for my emotions. I portioned out what I knew I could eat (one cup), put on plenty of butter, and chowed down. I then refrigerated the rest and made a dinner casserole out of it the next day. Sure I cursed a bit because I couldn't indulge myself, but on most levels, I was glad I couldn't.
I spent a lot of time going through my clothes (old and new), sorting, organizing, and sizing clothes for my next bit of lost weight. Seeing the tangible changes in my clothing sizes really helped me to realize that I had (have) indeed lost weight AND volume.
6. The Dreaded “E” Word: Exercise!
How long after surgery did you start exercising?
6. The Dreaded “E” Word: Exercise!
How long after surgery did you start exercising?
Uh... never. I'm bad.
What kind of exercise do you do, and how frequently?
What kind of exercise do you do, and how frequently?
Since the first of this year I've been participating in "100 days of activity". I'm up to day 42. I do square dance once a week.
Not to my success since I rarely do it. I want to, but I don't.
7. Issues with loose skin/plastic surgery
Have you had any issues with loose skin?
I'm 55 years old. I've been blessed with pretty good skin (in general.... thank you Mom). My body is a bit "droopy" but I'll repeat, I'm 55 years old. ;) The only part that really bothers me is my arms. I have major bat-wings and that is about the only part of my body that I can't hide.
7. Issues with loose skin/plastic surgery
Have you had any issues with loose skin?
I'm 55 years old. I've been blessed with pretty good skin (in general.... thank you Mom). My body is a bit "droopy" but I'll repeat, I'm 55 years old. ;) The only part that really bothers me is my arms. I have major bat-wings and that is about the only part of my body that I can't hide.
What are your thoughts about plastic surgery?
I'm considering brachioplasty for my wings. I was going to do it this spring but instead, I have a dog that needed his ACL repaired. My surgery is still a possibility depending on finances. I either have to do it soon or wait until the fall.
8. Anything else to tell us?
8. Anything else to tell us?
No great words of wisdom except to not give up on yourself. You need to work with the band, not against it.
Robin has promised to post more before/after photos on her blog but with her busy, busy life right now needs to find the time. She has a page coming soon but here is a preview of some of the pictures she sent to show you the changes she has experienced.
Thank you so much Robin, for sharing your story with us. Through others we learn and through others we inspire.
Robin has promised to post more before/after photos on her blog but with her busy, busy life right now needs to find the time. She has a page coming soon but here is a preview of some of the pictures she sent to show you the changes she has experienced.
2008
May 2009
May 2010
August 2010
October 2010
December 2010
March 2011
July 2011
Some family pics!
(Missing Backie)
View from the house.


























